Cigarette Substitutes
When I kicked the smoking habit last year, there were times I needed something in my mouth to replace the cigarettes. Most often, I popped a nicotine lozenge. Hard candies also worked well. A couple of times, I sucked on unlit cigarettes. I bit my nails too, but I do that anyway. (I know. I know. My nails always look terrible. I need to get that nasty-tasting substance used to get kids off of their thumb-sucking addiction.)
I found that having something that had to dissolve very slowly in my mouth helped me forget cravings. The nicotine lozenge should not be bitten into or swallowed, so it was a good smoking cessation aid for me. Of course, there was the time that I nearly choked on one.
I drafted the following list of cigarette substitutes last year:
Substitutes that Feel More Like Cigarettes
- A plastic straw cut to the length of a cigarette
- Cinnamon sticks (the real deal, available in the spices section of most grocery stores)
- Carrot or celery sticks
- Sugar-free hard candy sticks
- Licorice sticks
Other Oral Options
- Crunchy fruit or vegetables
- Sugarless gum, mints or candy
- Your little finger
A reader said she’d used glue sticks. The size is right, but I’m not sure if they’re toxic.
New Additions
- Get a sampler pack of herbal teas and try all of them
- Sunflower seeds, pistachios or pumpkin seeds
- Pretzel sticks or wands
- Jerky or fruit leather
- Drink a lot of water
I’ll keep thinking about substitutes. It would be great to have your ideas, too.


August 17th, 2007 16:20
At home or at work I’d keep a supply of kids ‘freezies’ or popcicles handy as a substitute.
As for something to keep my hands busy; a piece of string for ‘cats cradle’ sorts of diversion; a small ball to bounce; a packet of crayons and a pad for sponateous expressions of ‘the moment’.
Basically, anything that may help when I’m feeling stuck.